PDF

Theranostics 2020; 10(25):11837-11861. doi:10.7150/thno.49784 This issue Cite

Review

NIR light-assisted phototherapies for bone-related diseases and bone tissue regeneration: A systematic review

Zhuqing Wan, Ping Zhang, Longwei Lv , Yongsheng Zhou

Department of Prosthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology; National Engineering Laboratory for Digital and Material Technology of Stomatology; National clinical Research Center for Oral Diseases; Beijing Key Laboratory of Digital Stomatology, 22 Zhongguancun Avenue South, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, PR China.

✉ Corresponding authors: Yongsheng Zhou, Department of Prosthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology, 22 Zhongguancun Avenue South, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, P.R. China. Office: 86-10-82195070. Fax: 86-10-62173402. E-mail: kqzhouyshpku.edu.cn; Longwei Lv, Department of Prosthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology, 22 Zhongguancun Avenue South, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, P.R. China. E-mail: lvlwedu.cn More

Abstract

Recently, the rapid development of biomaterials has induced great interest in the precisely targeted treatment of bone-related diseases, including bone cancers, infections, and inflammation. Realizing noninvasive therapeutic effects, as well as improving bone tissue regeneration, is essential for the success of bone‑related disease therapies. In recent years, researchers have focused on the development of stimuli-responsive strategies to treat bone-related diseases and to realize bone regeneration. Among the various external stimuli for targeted therapy, near infrared (NIR) light has attracted considerable interests due to its high tissue penetration capacity, minimal damage toward normal tissues, and easy remote control properties. The main objective of this systematic review was to reveal the current applications of NIR light-assisted phototherapy for bone-related disease treatment and bone tissue regeneration. Database collection was completed by June 1, 2020, and a total of 81 relevant studies were finally included. We outlined the various therapeutic applications of photothermal, photodynamic and photobiomodulation effects under NIR light irradiation for bone‑related disease treatment and bone regeneration, based on the retrieved literatures. In addition, the advantages and promising applications of NIR light-responsive drug delivery systems for spatiotemporal-controlled therapy were summarized. These findings have revealed that NIR light-assisted phototherapy plays an important role in bone-related disease treatment and bone tissue regeneration, with significant promise for further biomedical and clinical applications.

Keywords: Near infrared light, phototherapy, drug delivery systems, bone-related diseases, bone tissue regeneration

Introduction

Bone-related diseases such as cancers, infection, and trauma, are common clinical problems that lead to irreparable bone defects, which remains an intractable problem for clinicians, leading to ongoing suffering for patients, and representing a burden to healthcare systems [1]. To develop a precise treatment to minimize the adverse influence on the surrounding healthy tissues and to maximize the efficacy of osteogenesis and bone tissue regeneration, selective targeted therapeutic strategies have been investigated [2]. Various strategies have been proposed for the targeted therapy of disease regions. A noninvasive technique utilizing external stimulation to control the therapeutic effect on the targeted tissues is an ideal solution [3-5].

Among several external stimuli‑responsive therapy approaches, those using light irradiation have attracted significant attention. The commonly used light for photoresponsive therapies can be generally divided into three subcategories: ultraviolet (UV) (200-400 nm), visible (Vis) (400-700 nm), and near infrared (NIR) (700-1300 nm) lights [3]. The choice of different phototherapies in clinical applications is related to the tissue penetration depth of light, which is wavelength-dependent. Compared with UV and Vis lights, NIR light exhibits a higher tissue penetration depth because of its minimum refraction and attenuation by endogenous biomolecules and chromophores (e.g., water, blood, and melanin). For instance, the tissue penetration depth of the rat skin is 7.5 ± 0.5 mm at λ = 705 nm, 6.3 ± 0.5 mm at λ = 633 nm, and only 1.0 ± 0.02 mm at λ = 408 nm, respectively [6]. In vivo studies in male rats also showed that an 810 nm laser could penetrate 51% through the skull and 40% through the scalp and skull combined in the prefrontal regions. In terms of 660 nm, only 5.8% of light could pass through the scalp plus skull and reach the cortical surface [7]. Moreover, the NIR light can be easily controlled in space and time, representing a promising alternative for precisely targeted therapies in vitro and in vivo. The controlled use of NIR light as an external stimulus is also highly biocompatible, with little toxicity or injurious effects on normal tissues [8]. Therefore, NIR light-assisted phototherapy, which realizes effective, noninvasive, precisely controlled therapeutic effects, has attracted increased research attention, leading to multiple solutions in a wide range of fields.

With the rapid development of nanotechnology, a series of NIR light-responsive nanomaterials with specific light absorbance and conversion abilities in NIR light windows have revealed marked potential for phototherapy strategies. Many kinds of nanomaterials, such as carbon-based nanomaterials, metal nanostructures, metal sulfides or oxides, and other organic or inorganic nanostructures, have attracted interest because of their NIR light-responsive properties [9]. These NIR light‑responsive nanomaterials have been widely exploited not only for disease diagnosis, but also for photothermal therapy (PTT), photodynamic therapy (PDT), and drug delivery systems because of their good photostability, efficient photothermal conversion ability, and minimal toxicity to normal cells and tissues. One commonly used phototherapy strategy, PTT, directly utilizes photoabsorbing agents to convert the photo energy of the penetrating NIR light into thermal effects, which can be used to ablate nearby abnormal tissues, with minimal damage to normal cells. Contrastingly, during PDT, photosensitizer molecules can generate reactive oxygen species (ROS) under NIR light irradiation, which have a targeted phototherapeutic effect on pathological tissues [2, 8]. The local hyperthermia and high ROS concentration have shown stable anticancer performance in vitro and in vivo [10, 11]. Furthermore, NIR light-responsive drug delivery systems have been proposed based on the photothermal and photodynamic effects of nanomaterials. These NIR light-responsive drug delivery systems are able to trigger the controlled release of the encapsulated therapeutics to enhance their therapeutic efficacy [12].

As a noninvasive spatiotemporal controlled treatment technology, NIR light‑assisted phototherapy has played an important role in clinical therapies of many diseases. To date, existing published reviews have mainly summarized the development of NIR light-responsive nanomaterials and their clinical applications for bioimaging and phototherapeutic effect in cancer therapies [11, 13, 14]. However, few reviews have discussed NIR light-assisted phototherapies for bone-related diseases and bone tissue regeneration. Recent studies have reported NIR light-induced antibacterial and anti‑inflammatory therapeutic effects for the treatment of bone‑related diseases [15-18]. At the same time, several studies have demonstrated that NIR light triggered mild localized heat, and the photoelectronic microenvironment could accelerate bone tissue regeneration [19, 20]. Moreover, NIR light-responsive drug delivery systems have not only been used for targeted cancer therapies, but also for the delivery of growth factors for bone tissue regeneration [21, 22]. These latest studies have revealed that NIR light‑assisted phototherapy is likely to realize more precise and less invasive therapeutic solutions not only for bone cancers, but also for implant infections, osteochondral inflammation, and bone tissue regeneration. In addition, another photoinduced strategy, photobiomodulation therapy, has been proposed for bone disease treatment and tissue regeneration. However, the above applications of NIR light‑assisted treatment have not yet been reviewed.

Therefore, this article systematically reviews the recent progress of NIR light‑associated phototherapies for bone-related diseases and bone tissue regeneration, intending to reach a general audience comprising not only medical scientists and clinicians, but also material scientists and engineers. Moreover, the current challenges and perspectives within the development of NIR light-assisted phototherapies for further clinical applications are proposed and discussed. A systematic understanding of NIR light-assisted phototherapies would help to achieve the desired therapeutic effects in the treatment of bone-related diseases, providing penetrating insights into precision medicine and regenerative medicine.

Methods

A primary database collection was constructed for all relevant publications in English (January 1, 1950 - June 1, 2020) based on three databases (PubMed, MEDLINE, and the Web of Science). The following keywords and their combination were used: (NIR OR (near infrared) OR (near infrared light) OR (near infrared laser)) AND bone AND (therapy OR treatment). The keyword search resulted in 1333 initial articles (June 1, 2020). The initial articles were screened based on the following inclusion and exclusion criteria:

Inclusion criteria: 1) Articles focused on bone disease treatment, such as bone cancers, bone infections, osteoarthritis, bone metabolic diseases, bone defect repair, and bone tissue regeneration; 2) only studies using NIR light as the treatment method; and 3) only phototherapies under the NIR light irradiation within the biological window of NIR light (700-1300 nm).

Exclusion criteria included: 1) Duplicate studies; 2) books, reviews, meetings, letters, literature updates, and laboratory protocols; 3) studies using NIR light in the detection and imaging of bone-related diseases (such as NIR spectroscopy for skeletal muscle oxygenation and hemodynamics monitoring, NIR spectroscopy for progressive degeneration of cartilage and bone monitoring, NIR spectrometry for material characterization, and NIR fluorescence for in vivo molecule, cell or tissue imaging); 4) articles in languages other than English; and 5) articles without full text (abstract only).

Titles or abstracts of the initially retrieved articles were evaluated for inclusion. Each article was reviewed by two researchers independently. When the title and abstract could not be excluded, the full text of the article was evaluated. This resulted in 71 articles fulfilling the eligibility criteria. In addition, reference tracking of the included publications was completed and all the relevant articles were checked and added. Finally, a total of 81 articles were fully examined for discussion in this systematic review (Figure 1).

 Figure 1 

Flowchart for the study screening and selection process, and reasons for inclusion/exclusion. N = number of publications. NIR, near infrared.

Results

Literature search output

Among the 81 included studies, PTT and PDT were used in 39 and 3 studies, respectively, while 11 studies introduced a combined use of PTT and PDT for the treatment of bone-related diseases. NIR light-assisted phototherapies have been used to treat different bone-related diseases (44 studies). The most common types of diseases were osteosarcoma (19 studies), bone metastasis of breast cancer (6 studies), implant‑related infections (8 studies), rheumatoid arthritis (3 studies), and osteoarthritis (1 study). Meanwhile, NIR light-assisted phototherapies have been used to accelerate bone tissue regeneration (13 studies). Twelve of these studies focused on NIR light‑responsive delivery systems to trigger the spatiotemporal controlled release of drugs or molecules to enhance the therapeutic effects to treat bone-related diseases.

Moreover, 24 studies reported the photobiomodulation effects of NIR light irradiation upon cells and tissues, including 8 studies that discussed the photobiomodulation effects on stem cells, and 16 studies that focused on the effect of photobiomodulation therapy on bone healing and dental treatment (Figure 2).

Summary of NIR light-responsive nanomaterials and NIR light radiation conditions

In the 81 included studies, 28 types of photosensitive agents were reported for their superior photothermal and photodynamic performances. These agents comprised a series of biocompatible photothermal transduction agents or photosensitizers based on metal, carbon, transition metal dichalcogenides, polymers, and semiconductors, which have significant NIR light-absorption ability and superior light-responsive capabilities [15, 23-26]. They have high photothermal conversion efficiency to generate heat and good photocatalytic characteristics to produce ROS in the NIR region [20, 27, 28]. They can also convert NIR light into the secondary local energy, which induces structural changes in drug carriers to trigger drug release [29]. The most commonly used NIR light-responsive biomaterials in the included studies were carbon-based nanomaterials (13 studies), metal nanostructures (11 studies), metal oxide nanoparticles (8 studies), metal sulfide nanostructures (9 studies), and black or red phosphorus (7 studies). The current most commonly used NIR light-responsive nanomaterials are summarized in Figure 3.

Moreover, to investigate the most suitable radiation conditions, we obtained an overview of the wavelength of the NIR light, the power density and the radiation time used in the different studies and their photothermal or photodynamic effects. The most commonly used window of NIR light for biological application was the NIR-I window (700-1000 nm). NIR light can be generated via many types of available lasers, such as Nd:YAG (neodymium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet) or diode lasers. Most studies (45/81) delivered the NIR light irradiation via an 808 nm diode laser module with fiber coupling. By contrast, phototherapies using NIR coherent (lasers) or noncoherent infrared light (light-emitting diodes, LED) have been investigated for their photobiomodulation effects on stem cells and bone tissue regeneration. Eighteen studies reported the photobiomodulation effect of low level or high frequency NIR laser therapy, while six studies investigated the effect of NIR LED photobiomodulation on cells and tissues.

 Figure 2 

A pie chart representing the number and distribution of different applications of NIR light-assisted phototherapies in the included articles. NIR, near infrared.

 Figure 3 

A summary of the current most commonly used NIR light-responsive nanomaterials. NIR, near infrared.

Discussion

The results of the literature search showed NIR light-assisted phototherapy exhibited great potential for the precise and controlled treatment of bone-related diseases and bone tissue regeneration because of its deep tissue penetration ability, high spatiotemporal resolution, and the unique biocompatibility of NIR light irradiation. Compared with other traditional therapy strategies, these phototherapies are considered as more minimally invasive, easily controlled, and precise to achieve the desired therapeutic effects and avoid damage to normal tissues. In this systematic review, these NIR light-assisted treatment strategies for bone-related disease and bone tissue regeneration are summarized, based on their mechanisms and applications.

NIR light-assisted phototherapy for bone cancers

Bone cancers generally refer to malignant bone tumors, including autologous skeletal system cancers (such as osteosarcoma and chondrosarcoma) and bone metastasis of cancers from other tissues (primary cancers in the lung, breast, and prostate) [30, 31]. Compared with traditional cancer radiotherapy strategies, NIR light-assisted targeted phototherapies, inducing PTT and PDT, mainly occur in cancer tissues and cause no obvious damage to normal tissues, thus minimizing adverse side effects [32-34]. PTT can exploit a local heating effect to realize the ablation of cancer tissues by combining light-absorbing materials with NIR light irradiation. The use of NIR light as an external stimulus allows for remote and high spatiotemporal control of local heating, leading to irreversible destruction of cancer tissue [35]. Hyperthermia over 50 °C, followed by NIR light irradiation, can cause irreversible DNA and protein denaturation in cancer regions [36]. Contrastingly, in PTT, the photosensitizer enters an excited state after NIR light radiation and generates various ROS from molecular oxygen. This NIR light‑induced release of ROS in PDT can kill cancer cells and damage the cancer vasculature, depriving the cancer of oxygen and nutrients [12, 37].

With the rapid development of nanotechnology, a series of NIR light-responsive nanomaterials have emerged and shown great advantages for efficient bone cancer phototherapy by serving as photothermal agents for PTT or as photosensitizers for PDT. [38-40]. According to the different administration methods, there are three main applications of these NIR light-responsive nanomaterials for bone cancer therapy. Firstly, these nanomaterials could be injected intravenously. The prolonged blood circulation time and the targeted tumor accumulation effects of these nanomaterials make highly efficient in vivo PTT and PDT possible, offering promising options for the treatment of the primary bone cancers or problematic cancer bone metastasis from other tissues [41]. However, the direct intravenous injection of nanomaterials might cause in vivo toxicity. The biosafety of these NIR light-responsive nanomaterials should be confirmed by testing normal hematology parameters to minimize the potential side effects [42]. Secondly, these NIR light-responsive nanomaterials can be integrated into scaffolds for combinatory bone cancer therapy and tissue regeneration. Considering that a few bone tumor cells inevitably remain around the bone defect after surgical intervention, the implanted bifunctional scaffolds could exhibit not only prominent photothermal and photodynamic performances, but also outstanding bone regeneration capabilities, which provide optimal alternatives for the treatment of large bone tumors and tumor-initiated bone defects [31, 43-45]. Thirdly, these NIR light-responsive nanomaterials could also be integrated into NIR light-triggered drug release systems, exhibiting versatility via their precise and controlled release of anticancer drugs [12]. NIR light-absorbing nanomaterial‑doped drug-carriers could exhibit outstanding photothermal and photodynamic therapeutic effects, as well as superb anticancer drug encapsulation efficiency, through intravenous administration, serving as promising candidates for bone cancer therapies [46]. In this section, we will introduce these three applications of NIR light-assisted phototherapy for bone cancers based on three different administrations. The mechanisms of these applications are shown in Figure 4.

 Figure 4 

Schematic illustration showing the applications of NIR light-responsive nanomaterials, NIR light-responsive bone scaffolds, and NIR light-triggered drug delivery systems for bone cancer therapy. The NIR light-responsive nanomaterials (A) and scaffolds (B) with the specific features of highly efficient photothermal conversion and controllable ROS release provide an effective biomaterial platform for the phototherapy of bone cancers. C. The NIR light-triggered drug delivery systems can realize controlled release of the encapsulated anti-tumor drugs for bone cancer chemotherapy. NIR, near infrared; ROS, reactive oxygen species.

NIR light-responsive nanomaterials in the phototherapy of bone cancers

The efficiency of anticancer phototherapy depends on the photothermal and photodynamic performances of the employed NIR light-responsive nanomaterials. Several nanomaterials, such as carbon-based nanomaterials [47], metal nanoparticles [48], and ceramic-based nanomaterials [32] are being developed for bone cancer phototherapies because of their efficient photothermal conversion function under NIR light irradiation after direct intravenous administration. A series of carbon-based nanomaterials have been widely used in NIR light-assisted phototherapies because of their excellent photothermal performances under the NIR light irradiation. For example, nanosized graphene oxide (GO) has been used as a localized, minimally invasive therapeutic approach for osteosarcoma therapy by inducing hyperthermia-medicated membrane damage of cancer cells under 808 nm NIR irradiation [47]. Similarly, multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWNTs) can also result in an efficient hyperthermia under 808 nm NIR irradiation and could remarkably suppress the growth of tumors, reducing the amount of cancer-induced bone destruction [49]. At the same time, metal nanoparticles, such as the classical platinum nanoparticles, could display enhanced accumulation at cancer-bearing bone lesions and inhibit the growth of bone cancer via PTT under an 808 nm NIR laser irradiation [48, 50]. Jie et al. reported a novel kind of oxygen vacancy-rich tungsten bronze nanoparticle (Na_xWO₃) against breast cancer osteolytic bone metastasis, which acts via the desirable photothermal effect under NIR laser irradiation [51]. This treatment strategy could also inhibit the osteoclastic RANKL and Sclerostin expression from tumor cells, thus further attenuating downstream osteoclastogenesis. Notably, the shapes of these nanoparticles can change their photoresponsive properties, and NIR absorbing nanorods and nanocages have been preferred for in vivo applications [4]. The heat released by these nanoparticles under NIR light irradiation would efficiently kill cancer cells via photothermal ablation. Meanwhile, these nanosized particles can be cleared efficiently via the kidneys, decreasing their long-term toxicity in clinical applications [50].

Alternatively, the tissue penetration efficacy of NIR light would also influence the efficiency of anticancer phototherapies. The biological window of NIR light can be divided into NIR-I (700-1000 nm), and NIR-II (1000-1300 nm) biowindows [32, 52]. To date, the NIR-I biowindow has been more commonly used in phototherapies because most kinds of NIR light-responsive nanomaterials have exhibited favorable photothermal and photodynamic properties in the NIR-I biowindow. Considering that the tissue penetration depth of light increases with increasing wavelength, the NIR-II biowindow exhibits deeper tissue penetration compared with the NIR-I light. It would be helpful to develop efficient photoresponsive nanomaterials with high NIR-II absorbance [35, 42]. Recently, a new family of two dimensional (2D) nanomaterials, named MXenes, have generated great interest because of their unique physiochemical performance and excellent photothermal conversion efficiency [53]. These 2D nanomaterials, which comprise transition metal carbides, nitrides, or carbonitrides, have displayed highly efficient in vivo photothermal performance in both the NIR-I and NIR-II windows [54]. For example, Lin's group reported a 2D niobium carbide (Nb₂C), a novel kind of MXene, with an extraordinarily high efficiency of photothermal conversion for bone tumor ablation [32]. They revealed its highly efficient in vitro and in vivo photothermal cancer therapies in both NIR-I (36.4%) and NIR-II (45.65%) biowindows. Similarly, hybrid carbon dots (CDs)/WS₂ heterojunctions have also been reported for NIR-II enhanced PTT of osteosarcoma. These CDs/WS₂ heterojunctions exhibited improved cancer targeting ability after intravenous injection and efficient photothermal conversion under the 1064 nm laser irradiation. The deep tissue penetration ability in the NIR-II biowindow means that the satisfying ablation of cancer tissues can be realized at relatively low laser exposure, even when being covered by a 10 mm thick additional tissue. Although the NIR-II biowindow has attracted great attention for tumor xenografts, to date, it has rarely been used for bone cancer therapies, mainly because of a lack of suitable photosensitive agents with desirable strong absorption and high efficiency of photothermal conversion in the NIR-II biowindow [32, 55-57]. More effort should be made to develop efficient light-responsive nanomaterials with high NIR-II absorbance to broaden the application prospects of NIR light-assisted phototherapies for bone cancer.

Meanwhile, nanomaterials can serve as an effective photosensitizer to generate ROS after NIR light irradiation for photodynamic therapy in bone cancer therapy. Pd‑bacteriopheophorbide has been reported as a photosensitizer that induces PDT, leading to hypoxia, necrosis, and eradication of prostate cancer bone metastasis [41]. This photosensitizer could target the tumor vasculature after direct intravenous administration and is cleared rapidly from the circulation within a few hours. Raucci et al. [58] proposed ultrathin 2D black phosphorous (BP) as a promising candidate for osteosarcoma therapy because of its photodynamic effect. 2D BP could inhibit the metabolic activity of osteosarcoma cells and induce the proliferation and osteogenic differentiation of human preosteoblast cells in vitro, thus playing important roles in anticancer therapies and regenerative medicine. The nanomaterials and the different radiation conditions used in current bone cancer phototherapies are summarized in Table 1. These nanomaterials show great promise for bone cancer therapy and bone tissue engineering.

NIR light-responsive scaffolds for the phototherapy of bone cancers

Massive cancer-induced bone defects and residual cancer cells are two critical problems in the prognosis of bone cancers. It is essential to fabricate multifunctional scaffolds endowed with the ability to eradicate cancer cells and remodel bone tissue simultaneously during bone cancer therapy [31]. In the present review, a series of strategies have been proposed to combine NIR light-responsive nanomaterials with 3D printed scaffolds for bone defect repair after the resection of cancer tissue. These 3D printed scaffolds, such as bioactive glass (BG) scaffolds and tricalcium phosphate (TCP) scaffolds are commonly used scaffolds for bone tissue engineering. The combination of these bioactive BG scaffolds with NIR light-absorbing agents could endow the scaffolds with excellent photothermal and photodynamic therapeutic effects after implantation into the tumor-induced bone defects. Furthermore, the implanted bioactive scaffolds could also facilitate new bone formation by stimulating the osteogenic differentiation of bone mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) [59]. The favorable osteogenic ability of these scaffolds is mainly attributed to their interconnected macropore structure for nutrient transportation and the gradual release of elements (such as Ca, P, and Si) during the degradation process [43, 59]. Currently, a series of bifunctional scaffolds have been developed based on the constantly emerging NIR light-responsive nanomaterials. The main methods and conclusions of relevant studies are listed in Table 2.

The classical metal nanomaterials have generated great interest because of their excellent photothermal conversion performance in anticancer therapies. It has been reported that bismuth-doped BG scaffolds displayed high photothermal conversion efficiency to induce hyperthermia for osteosarcoma treatment [60]. Meanwhile, multiple kinds of metal oxide nanoparticles have been used as photoabsorbers to kill cancer cells. Zhang's groups have reported a black TiO₂ nanoparticles-coated Ti6Al4V implant for the reconstruction of large bone defects followed by surgical resection of bone cancers [61]. The black TiO₂ nanoparticle coating endowed the implant with good biocompatibility, strong NIR light absorbance, and efficient photothermal conversion ability under 808 nm laser irradiation. Similarly, magnetic iron oxide nanoparticles, such as Fe₃O₄ nanoparticles and M-type ferrite nanoparticles (SrFe₁₂O₁₉), could serve as photothermal agents in scaffolds. These scaffolds could exhibit photothermal anticancer therapeutic abilities and enhanced bone regeneration simultaneously [62-64]. Meanwhile, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), such as copper coordinated tetrakis (4‑carboxyphenyl) porphyrin (Cu-TCPP) also have strong NIR light absorption [65]. The released bioactive ions of the Cu-TCPP combined with TCP scaffolds can simultaneously stimulate osteogenesis and angiogenesis in the bone defect. Moreover, a copper-based CuFeSe₂ nanocrystal, a kind of semiconductor, has been reported as a new class of efficient photothermal agent. By functionalization with the CuFeSe₂ nanocrystals, 3D printed BG scaffolds exhibited excellent photothermal performance under 808 nm laser irradiation [43]. Another kind of PTT agent, MoS₂ nanosheets, has also been introduced into BG scaffolds for anticancer treatment and bone tissue regeneration [66]. Besides these inorganic nanomaterials, a kind of NIR light-absorbing organic charge-transfer cocrystal with great photothermal conversion performance has also been integrated into BG scaffolds to fabricate bifunctional therapeutic implants [45]. Additionally, organic NIR light-responsive biomaterials modification, such as dopamine modification, would also provide scaffolds with an excellent NIR photothermal effect [67]. These modified bifunctional scaffolds could be implanted precisely into the tumor sites and could induce effective local hyperthermia (over 50 °C) under the NIR light irradiation, which resulted in enhanced tumor cell apoptosis and tumor ablation. After irradiation, the mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) could migrate to the bone defects gradually and attach, proliferate, and differentiate on the bioactive scaffolds, leading to long-term bone regeneration.

In addition, carbon-based nanomaterials, such as GO and single-/multi-walled carbon nanotubes, offer great promise for cancer photothermal therapies because of their strong NIR light absorbance, excellent photothermal performance and satisfactory cytocompatibility [68-71]. It also has been reported that carbon-based nanomaterials can effectively improve bone regeneration by inducing the directional migration and osteogenic differentiation of BMSCs [72, 73]. For example, GO‑modified biofunctional tricalcium silicate bone cement and TCP bone scaffolds have been fabricated for cancer therapy and bone tissue regeneration [59, 71]. The MWNT-modified scaffold also exhibited high photothermal performance in the treatment of cancer related bone defects [70]. Zero dimensional carbon dots are another kind of carbon-based nanomaterial. They can bind specifically to calcified bones and have been used to eliminate osteosarcoma and enhance bone tissue regeneration [68]. In vitro and in vivo studies of these carbon-based nanomaterial-coated scaffolds have successfully demonstrated their bifunctional properties of photothermal therapy and bone regeneration, which could pave the way for the design and fabrication of novel implants with simultaneous bone cancer killing and bone tissue-remodeling capacity.

With the rapid advance of nanotechnology, a series of new nanomaterials, including MXenes and Lanthanide (Ln) nanomaterials, have also been incorporated into bone scaffolds for cancer phototherapies recently. MXene nanosheets, such as 2D Ti₃C₂ MXene and Nb₂C MXene, have unique structural characteristics, including a large specific surface area and adjustable physiochemical properties. They display enriched photothermal and photodynamic therapeutic effects in both the NIR-I and NIR-II biowindows, providing intriguing biomaterial platforms for the diversified treatment of bone cancers [31, 44]. LaB₆, a chemical compound of La and B elements, also shows efficient NIR photothermal conversion ability. The LaB₆-modified TCP scaffold is an ideal option for both the ablation of bone cancers and the repair of defect regions [74]. The emergence of these novel photothermal agents has provided the possibility for the development of NIR light-responsive scaffolds, offering new avenues to construct highly efficient therapeutic platforms for bone caners.

NIR light-triggered drug delivery systems for bone cancer chemotherapy

Controlled drug delivery systems exhibit an enhanced therapeutic efficiency as well as reduced systemic toxicity compared with conventional bone cancer chemotherapies. Photothermal (generation of heat) and photodynamic (production of ROS) mechanisms could be used to break, isomerize, or rearrange molecules and achieve drug release. After reaching the cancer tissues, the drug delivery systems can be triggered by NIR light to realize controlled release of the encapsulated therapeutics [12]. The energy of NIR light radiation could be converted into heat in photothermal systems. This heat conversion can change the physicochemical properties of thermoresponsive agents in drug delivery systems, resulting in drug release [12, 75]. In the photodynamic-induced release system, the photosensitizer generates singlet oxygen (¹O₂) from molecular oxygen after NIR light radiation and mediates the PDT. The highly active ¹O₂ interacts with the specific molecule in the drug delivery system, leading to a structural change that triggers drug release [12, 75].

Considering that the well-distributed porous structure of mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNs) is promising for drug loading and encapsulation, a series of NIR light-absorbing agent-doped MSNs have been designed for photochemotherapy of bone cancer. For example, Lu et al. [46] designed novel bismuth sulfide (BS)@MSNs to deliver doxorubicin (DOX), a classical anticancer drug, to treat osteosarcoma. The outstanding photothermal effect of the BS nanoparticles not only controlled the release of DOX, but also induced cell death, exerting a combined bone-targeted chemothermal therapeutic effect. Xue's group also engineered a biodegradable polydopamine (PDA) coated bioactive glass nanoparticle platform for on-demand NIR light-triggered anticancer drug (DOX) release and photothermal ablation of bone cancers [76]. Similarly, Sun's group have designed a gold nanorod-decorated mesoporous silica nanoparticle to deliver zoledronic acid (ZOL), which exhibits strong bone affinity and efficient anticancer abilities for breast cancer bone metastasis [77].

In addition, mussel-inspired PDA nanoparticles also possess efficient photothermal conversion and intrinsic drug anchoring abilities [78, 79]. They have been used widely as versatile carriers for anti-tumor drug delivery in the photochemotherapy of bone cancer. For example, Wang's groups have designed alendronate (ALN)-anchored PDA nanoparticles to release the anticancer drug, 7-ethyl-10-hydroxycamptothecin [80]. Similarly, injectable chitosan hydrogels containing PDA-decorated hydroxyapatite (HAp) nanoparticles could realize localized controlled and sustained release of cisplatin when exposed to NIR light [81]. Moreover, a kind of dual responsive drug delivery system, which could be triggered by both NIR laser irradiation and acidic stimulus, has been developed for bone cancer therapy. Gu et al. [82] reported a bovine serum albumin-bioinspired iridium oxide nanosystem for chemophotothermal therapy of osteosarcoma. This nanosystem displayed both NIR light and pH-responsive DOX release profiles in vitro, which enhanced the therapeutic anticancer effect. The above anticancer drug carrier systems could be administrated through intravenous injection and are mainly distributed to, and accumulated in, bone cancer tissues, displaying efficient photochemotherapeutic performance under NIR laser irradiation. The radiation parameters of NIR light-induced phototherapies, as well as the encapsulation and release efficiencies of these anticancer drug delivery systems, are summarized in Table 3.

NIR light-assisted phototherapy for bone infection and inflammation

In recent years, NIR light-assisted phototherapy has been recognized as a promising strategy, not only for anticancer therapy, but also for antibacterial and anti‑inflammation therapies [15, 58, 83]. The NIR light-responsive nanomaterials could be coated onto the bone implants, exhibiting outstanding photothermal and photodynamic therapeutic effects to destroy bacterial integrity or biofilm structure via hyperthermia and ROS generation [16]. Meanwhile, NIR light-responsive nanomaterials can be directly injected into the inflamed joints, inducing local heat under NIR irradiation and delivering ROS simultaneously to remove inflamed tissues [83]. Therefore, the current applications of NIR light-assisted phototherapies for classical implant-related bone infections, as well as common chronic arthritis, will be introduced and summarized in this section (Figure 5).

 Figure 5 

Schematic illustration revealing the mechanisms of NIR light-assisted phototherapy for bone infection and inflammation. A. NIR light-induced hyperthermia increases the bacterial membrane permeability under ROS stimulation, accelerating the eradication of the biofilm formed on the surface of the implants. B. The NIR light can penetrate the inflamed joints and generate local heat and ROS to eliminate inflamed tissues, decreasing the generation of inflammatory cytokines, synovial erosion, and tissue destruction. NIR, near infrared; ROS, reactive oxygen species.

NIR light-assisted phototherapy for implant-related infections

Massive bone defects caused by bone cancers, infections, fractures, and the increasing number of orthopedic diseases have led to a high demand for artificial implants [84]. Bacteria‑induced infections of artificial implants and insufficient bone tissue integration are still the main problems after implantation, which could lead to implant failure [85, 86]. The implant surface could provide appropriate conditions for bacteria to adhere and proliferate. Once a pathogenic biofilm forms on the implant surface, the host defense and conventional antibiotic treatment cannot work, leading to infections of the surrounding tissues [87, 88]. The implants coated with the NIR light-responsive nanomaterials have received increased attention because of their outstanding photothermal and photodynamic therapeutic performances. These implants could exhibit controlled, noninvasive, and nonsurgical antibacterial properties by generating heat and ROS. The antibacterial efficiency reached about 97% for Staphylococcus aureus at a hyperthermia of 88.8 °C for 15 min when photothermally triggered by NIR light [28]. Moreover, releasing ROS, such as ¹O₂, can damage cell membranes and cell walls of bacteria and kill the pathogens [89]. However, when using photothermal or photodynamic therapy alone, the excessive temperature caused by the photothermal effect or release of ROS during the photodynamic therapy could damage normal tissue and induce serious side effects. Therefore, it is desirable to combine the two therapies to kill bacteria. A high temperature of 50 °C can facilitate permeability of the bacterial membrane, making it easier to kill bacteria via ROS [27, 28]. In addition to efficient antibacterial properties, ideal bone implants should also display good biocompatibility and promote osteogenic capabilities. Based on these mechanisms, several studies have reported NIR light-assisted antibacterial coating on the surface of bone implants to treat implant-related infections. These NIR light-assisted antibacterial strategies are discussed in more detail below and are summarized in Table 4.

For example, mussel-inspired PDA is emerging as an excellent photothermal agent because of its good biocompatibility and efficient NIR light-responsive photothermal conversion. It has been reported that photosensitizer-loaded mesoporous PDA nanoparticles, as well as MoS₂/PDA-arginine-glycine-aspartic acid (RGD) decorations of bone implants, displayed synergistic photothermal and photodynamic effects for antibacterial therapy [16, 17]. Similarly, a hybrid BS@Ag₃PO₄ coating on bone implants also exhibited good photothermal effects using BS as photocatalyst [90]. The integration of Ag₃PO₄ also endows the implant with bacteriostatic properties. This NIR light-triggered inorganic hybrid semiconductor heterojunction-decoration system is biocompatible and effective to eliminate biofilms. In addition, red phosphorus has been proven to be an efficient photothermal coating on bone implants because of its good biocompatibility and more effective photothermal ability compared with BP. Its degradation products are mainly phosphate, which plays an important role in bone tissue regeneration [91]. Tan's group have reported a red phosphorus-IR780-RGDC (arginine-glycine-aspartic-acid-cysteine)-coated antibacterial titanium (Ti) bone implant [28, 92]. The outstanding photothermal effects of red phosphorus and the stable photodynamic effects of IR780 meant that the biofilm could be eliminated efficiently under a safe 808 nm NIR light irradiation at 50 °C, in vitro and in vivo, without damaging the normal tissues. At the same time, the RGDC decoration on the surface of the Ti implant enhanced the adhesion, proliferation, and osteogenic differentiation of MSCs. These coating strategies on the surfaces of bone implants have provided great promise for clinical orthopedic applications.

Hang et al. [27] have reported another dual light coirradiation system, including both 660 nm visible light and 808 nm NIR light, for biofilm elimination and osteointegration of bone implants. They designed a biocompatible TiO₂/MoS₂/PDA/RGD nanorod array on Ti implants, which could kill bacteria under dual light coirradiation and promoted the osteogenic capabilities of the implants. While the photothermal conversion ability of 660 nm is relatively weak, the yield of ROS under dual light irradiation is almost the sum of individual light irradiation, which enhanced the antibacterial ability of the implants. The physical puncture of the nanorods also contributed to the antibacterial properties of the implants. In addition, a novel photo-sonotherapy strategy has also been designed by fabricating an oxygen deficient S-doped TiO₂ coating on Ti implants, which exhibited significant sonodynamic and photothermal abilities [15]. This system achieved an extremely high antibacterial efficiency of 99.995% against Staphylococcus aureus under 15 min NIR light irradiation combined with ultrasound treatment. In addition, besides coating on the surface of bone implants, the NIR light-responsive nanomaterials could also be injected into the knee joint for the clinical treatment of periprosthetic joint infection. Liu et al. [93] has reported curcumin‑upconversion nanoparticles (curcumin-UCNPs) for the efficient eradication of drug-resistant bacteria in a deep joint infection by producing singlet oxygen under NIR light irradiation. Curcumin is an extract from the plant Curcuma longa, which has intrinsic antibacterial and anti-inflammatory properties. Compared with traditional therapeutic strategies, this research might offer a new alternative for periprosthetic joint infection.

In summary, the NIR light-assisted phototherapies have shown stable antibacterial photothermal and photodynamic therapeutic performances in vitro and in vivo, representing promising strategies to treat bone infections.

NIR light-assisted phototherapy for arthritis

Worldwide, the prevalence of arthritis is high, and includes over 100 types, of which the most common are rheumatoid arthritis, osteoarthritis, and inflammatory arthritis [94]. NIR light has sufficient penetration depth to reach the deep inflamed joints, which guarantees the efficacy of phototherapies and desirable therapeutic outcomes. NIR light-responsive nanomaterials could exhibit outstanding photothermal and photodynamic therapeutic effects for the anti-inflammation therapy via intra-articular injection, which is similar to the mechanisms in anticancer and antibacterial therapies. These photothermal materials could convert NIR light into localized heat and suppress the inflammatory reaction. In parallel, the photosensitizers in PDT can also be excited into their singlet state under NIR light irradiation, producing ROS to treat inflamed cells and tissues [83, 95]. These synergistic photothermal and photodynamic effects of NIR light-assisted phototherapies might decrease the synovium erosion, chronic inflammation activity, and bone and cartilage destruction, providing a promising approach for arthritis treatment [95].

Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a common chronic inflammatory disease that seriously affects the quality of life of the patients, leading to long standing synovitis, degradation of cartilage and bone tissue, and increased disability. Recently, NIR light‑assisted phototherapy including PTT and PDT, has received increased attention for noninvasive and spatiotemporal controlled RA treatment [96-98]. Nanoparticles with good biocompatibility, excellent photoresponsive ability, and intrinsic osteogenic/chondrogenic capabilities have significant advantages for RA phototherapies. Lu et al. [95] prepared novel _L-cysteine (Cys) assisted Cu_7.2S₄ nanoparticles to serve as photothermal agents for PTT and photosensitizers for PDT simultaneously. This kind of nanoparticle can be injected into the disease region and has full potential for RA treatment. Meanwhile, a novel therapeutic system that combined NIR light-responsive BP nanosheets with a platelet-rich plasma (PRP)‑modified chitosan thermoresponsive hydrogel has been prepared to treat RA [83]. The BP nanosheets generate mild local hyperthermia upon NIR light irradiation and release ROS into the inflamed joints simultaneously to eliminate hyperplastic synovial tissue. In addition, the degradation products of BP enhance the osteogenic process and the thermoresponsive hydrogel can serve as an anti‑inflammation drug carrier, reducing the friction between the surrounding tissues at the same time. These injectable NIR light-responsive systems can be used as efficient alternatives to anti-inflammation therapies for RA. The above-mentioned NIR light‑responsive phototherapy systems for RA are summarized in Table 5.

Moreover, NIR light-triggered drug delivery systems have been developed for arthritis treatment. As NIR light-triggered drug delivery systems for bone cancer chemotherapies, the photothermal and photodynamic mechanisms of NIR light could also be used to achieve drug release in arthritis treatment. Zhao et al. [99] reported a highly efficient photothermal-triggered drug delivery platform based on the molybdenum disulfide (MoS₂) nanosheets to control the release of dexamethasone for osteoarthritis therapy. This nanosystem could be used to treat osteoarthritis in vivo through intra-articular injection and the NIR light could control dexamethasone release remotely in the disease region, which could be modulated by adjusting the light‑radiation behavior. Similarly, cell membrane penetrating peptide‑modified mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNs) were reported to realize the efficient controlled release of triptolide, which is a traditional Chinese herbal medicine used to treat RA [100]. The MSNs modified with indocyanine green, a kind of photothermal agent, could effectively regulate the release of triptolide under 808 nm laser irradiation, leading to the development of noninvasive therapeutic approaches for RA. These strategies could serve as references for the design of other intra-articular drug delivery nanosystems and have marked potential for the clinical treatment of arthritis.

NIR light-assisted phototherapy for bone tissue regeneration

Recently, several strategies to accelerate bone tissue regeneration via NIR light‑assisted phototherapies have been proposed. The mild localized heat or photoelectric microenvironment triggered by NIR light irradiation can achieve noninvasive, remote, and spatiotemporally controlled cell differentiation behaviors, providing a unique strategy for bone tissue regeneration [19, 20]. In addition, considering that NIR light-responsive biosystems have been applied to realize the remote and controlled release of anticancer or antibacterial drugs, it also could be used to facilitate the controlled release of biological molecules (such as ions, drugs, or proteins) to promote bone tissue regeneration or promote tissue regeneration via a nonpharmacological and noninvasive strategy. At the same time, it is suggested that photobiomodulation therapy under NIR light irradiation could have a positive effect on bone metabolism, providing more inspirations for clinical applications in bone‑related disease treatment. At the cellular level, stem cells and progenitor cells appear to be particularly susceptible to photobiomodulation effects. NIR light-induced photon absorption mainly occurs in mitochondria. Numerous signaling pathways could be activated via the promoted oxidative metabolism within the mitochondria, leading to the activation of a series of transcription factors [101]. These transcription factors can lead to increased expression of genes that modulate the attachment, proliferation, and osteogenic differentiation of cells, playing important roles in accelerating wound healing and bone tissue regeneration [102]. Therefore, NIR light-assisted phototherapies have several advantages for bone tissue regeneration (Figure 6). These applications are summarized in the following sections.

 Figure 6 

Schematic illustration of the NIR light-induced photobiomodulation, photothermal effect, and NIR light-triggered osteogenic molecule release systems to regulate new bone formation. A. Photobiomodulation therapy under NIR light irradiation can modulate the attachment, proliferation, and differentiation of stem cells. B. Phototherapy based on the NIR light-responsive nanomaterials can induce mild local heat under NIR light irradiation, which enhances new bone formation. C. NIR light‑responsive release systems can realize the controlled release of osteogenic molecules, such as ions, drugs, and cytokines, to accelerate new bone formation. NIR, near infrared.

Phototherapy based on NIR light-responsive nanomaterials for bone tissue regeneration

Controlling cell fate through noninvasive in vitro stimulation can achieve precise and orchestrated biological activities in tissue engineering. It represents an appealing strategy to use NIR light radiation as a kind of tissue penetrative stimuli to gain nonpharmacological and noninvasive control of cell differentiation behaviors. For example, Fu et al. [20] designed a bismuth sulfide/hydroxyapatite (BS/HAp) film to build a rapid and repeatable NIR light-sensitive photoelectric extracellular microenvironment around Ti implants. The photoelectrons created under 808 nm laser radiation could tune the behavior of MSCs and control cell fate by regulating downstream gene expression towards osteogenic differentiation. This BS/HAp modification on an implant is highly encouraging and could achieve more precise control of cell fates in biological therapies. Similarly, Tiwari et al. reported a kind of NIR light-absorbing carbon nitride (C₃N₄) sheet, which enhances cellular proliferation and differentiation through runt-related transcription factor 2 (RUNX2) activation. The photocurrent upon two photon excitation of this small sized C₃N₄ sheet would induce a charge transfer and increased cytosolic Ca²⁺ accumulation, resulting in enhanced osteogenic differentiation of stem cells and new bone formation. In addition, single‑walled graphene nanoribbons have been reported to generate photoacoustic signals under 905 nm NIR laser radiation, which could serve as an anabolic stimulus for noninvasive bone defect repair in a rodent femoral fracture site [103].

By contrast, mild local heat (40-43 °C) has been reported to facilitate healing of bone defects via inducing the earlier differentiation of human MSCs (hMSCs) and promoting the maturation of osteoblasts differentiated from MSCs [104]. Several studies have reported the application of NIR light-triggered photothermal technology in bone tissue engineering. For example, classical NIR light responsive nanomaterials, such as metal nanoparticles, could serve as hyperthermal agents to promote bone tissue regeneration by producing mild localized heat. A kind of NIR light-responsive gold nanorod doped gelatin/HAp composite microsphere was successfully synthesized, which exhibited an efficient NIR light-triggered photothermal properties [105]. Zhang et al. [19] reported a photothermal strategy for in situ bone regeneration using porous AuPd alloy nanoparticles (pAuPds) as photothermal agents. The mild localized heat (around 40-43 °C) could greatly enhance cell proliferation and bone tissue regeneration via upregulating the expression of a series of osteogenesis-related genes and proteins. RNA sequencing analysis demonstrated that the Wnt signaling pathway was involved in in situ bone regeneration. Moreover, a new class of 2D BP nanosheets have been employed as photothermal agents for the remote control of bone regeneration [106, 107]. These BP nanosheets could upregulate the expression of heat shock proteins in human BMSCs and thus enhance bone tissue regeneration by remote control of NIR light irradiation. Moreover, BP can degrade into nontoxic phosphates and phosphonates in the biological environment, providing good nucleation sites for biomineralization [108, 109]. The BP-combined osteoimplants have good photothermal properties, biodegradability, and osteogenic abilities, thus providing new insights for orthopedic applications.

NIR light-responsive release systems for bone tissue regeneration

Although the use of NIR light-responsive drug delivery systems combining chemotherapy and photothermal therapy has exhibited versatility in bone cancer therapies, NIR light‑responsive release systems for bone tissue regeneration have not been widely used. NIR light has good tissue penetration, as well as accurate and spatiotemporal control properties. Remote control of cell fate could provide a versatile method to regulate bone regeneration therapies. Combining the use of tissue penetrative NIR light stimuli with NIR light-responsive nanomaterials is a delicate and efficient strategy for the intracellular control of stem cells. Recently, several strategies have been proposed to regulate the differentiation of stem cells based on NIR light-responsive release nanosystems. Kang et al. [110] designed an upconversion nanotransducer (UCNT)‑based nanosystem to regulate intracellular calcium by encapsulating either a calcium chelator or a calcium supplier under NIR light stimuli. An increase in calcium can promote the differentiation of hMSCs into osteoblasts. Strontium (Sr) is another osteoinductive element that could enhance bone formation. An NIR light-triggered Sr²⁺ delivery system was developed by incorporating SrCl₂ and BP nanosheets into poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) microspheres for bone tissue regeneration [29]. The spatiotemporal release of Sr²⁺ controlled by NIR light significantly improved bone tissue regeneration. These NIR light-triggered ion-release systems are suitable for bone regeneration therapies that require precise control at specific times.

Alternatively, the on-demand release of therapeutic proteins holds great promise for bone tissue regeneration. Tuncaboylu et al. [111] designed a shape-memory poly(ɛ-caprolactone) network to release several proteins, including stromal cell-derived factor 1α (SDF-1α), a chemotactic protein relevant to bone tissue regeneration. The diameter of these shape-memory tubes decreases under NIR light irradiation and expels the payload protein. Yin et al. [22] provided another strategy to fabricate a biomimetic anti‑inflammatory nanocapsule (BANC). The BANC is coated with lipopolysaccharide-treated macrophage cell membranes, loading resolvin D1 inside a gold nanocage as an “M2 polarization inducer”. Controlled release could be triggered under NIR light irradiation, promoting the healing process during bone tissue repair. Moreover, another heat-activated and dimerizer-dependent transgene expression system was designed based on an NIR light-responsive hydrogel to achieve spatiotemporal control of bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) [21]. The photothermal effect of hollow gold nanoparticles in hydrogels induced mild hyperthermia, which stimulated the cell constructs to express BMP-2 in the bone defect. These protein-release systems promote the formation of new mineralized bone tissue, providing promising strategies for bone tissue regeneration. These NIR light‑responsive drug release systems are summarized in Table 6.

Photobiomodulation therapy under NIR light irradiation for bone tissue regeneration

Photobiomodulation describes the photochemical reactions of cells and tissues achieved under red or NIR light irradiation with lower energy densities compared with other heat-mediated laser therapies, which induce tissue ablation or coagulation after irradiation [102, 112]. This light-based technique involves irradiation of tissue using lasers or LEDs. Laser light can reach the target tissue regions via a continuous or pulsed mode. The transmitted energy will trigger photochemical reactions instead of inducing a thermal effect, which can modulate cellular metabolic processes, including cell viability, proteins synthesis, and DNA/RNA expression [113]. Currently, photobiomodulation therapy under NIR light irradiation has been used clinically to reduce inflammation, edema, and pain, and to repair multiple damaged tissues, representing a promising alternative for bone disease treatment and bone tissue regeneration [112, 114]. For photobiomodulation therapy, two critical challenges must be overcome: One is the uncertainty about the mechanism underlying its beneficial effects, and the other is the optimal irradiation parameters [12]. In the following sections, the effects of photobiomodulation therapy on cellular behavior, the bone healing process, and dental treatments are discussed based on the published literature.

The effects of photobiomodulation therapy on cellular behavior

Stem cell therapy has attracted great interest in tissue regenerative medicine. Photobiomodulation therapy might increase the biological functions of MSCs. The primary action site of photobiomodulation under red or NIR light irradiation is the mitochondria, more specifically, cytochrome c oxidase. It is hypothesized that inhibitory nitric oxide dissociated from cytochrome c oxidase could restore electron transport and increase the mitochondrial membrane potential. By contrast, NIR light irradiation could trigger light or heat-gated ion channels and activate the change of transient receptor potential. These potential changes to mitochondria could increases the rate of respiration and ATP production, leading to a marked effect on stem cells via mitochondrial redox signaling [112]. Our literature review showed that the effect of photobiomodulation therapy for bone tissue regeneration not only depends on the type of cells, but also on the category of lasers, wavelength, density of energy, and the duration of photobiomodulation therapy. There is a wide variation in the parameters between different studies, making it difficult to compare the efficacy of photobiomodulation. Different types of cells, such as adipose-derived stem cells (ASCs) and BMSCs, might have different responses to photobiomodulation therapy [112]. It has been reported that photobiomodulation therapy with a combination of 630 and 810 nm lasers irradiation significantly enhanced cell viability and decreased the apoptosis of human ASCs and BMSCs in vitro, in which NIR light irradiation induced more in vitro cell viability of ASCs than BMSCs [115].

In addition, the effects of photobiomodulation therapy within different wavelengths are still being explored. Wavelengths from blue to NIR light have been demonstrated to enhance bone regeneration. Kunimatsu's group have reported that irradiation with a high frequency NIR diode laser is highly efficient to increase cell division and migration of osteoblasts via MAPK/ERK signaling and improved the bone tissue regeneration [116]. Under 1064-nm irradiation, equine MSCs remained viable and expressed increased concentrations of interleukin (IL)-10 and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), which enhanced the tissue healing process by decreasing the inflammatory reaction and promoting angiogenesis [117]. The cellular responses to NIR light irradiation demonstrate the great potential for the photobiomodulation effect on MSCs to enhance their therapeutic properties. Meanwhile, it has been reported that low-power irradiation by 635 and 809 nm lasers might not have obvious effects on osteoblast viability and proliferation [114]. Moreover, Wang's group have demonstrated that although red (660 nm) or NIR (810 nm) photobiomodulation therapies stimulated the proliferation of hASCs, the blue (415 nm), green (540 nm) wavelengths are more effective to stimulate the osteogenic differentiation of hASCs [118, 119]. Similarly, Tani et al. [120] reported that photobiomodulation therapy with a 635 nm laser was a more effective option to enhance the viability, proliferation, adhesion, and osteogenic differentiation of human MSCs compared with those of 808 nm and 405 nm irradiation. Therefore, the most promising range of wavelengths to promote the proliferation of osteoblasts and tissue regeneration is still controversial [114]. It is important to use appropriate irradiation parameters during laser treatment for bone tissue engineering.

Moreover, guiding the differentiation of MSCs by light is particularly attractive for bone tissue engineering and regenerative medicine. Yan's group constructed a controlled UCNPs-based substrate to guide multi-directional differentiation of MSCs by NIR light irradiation [121]. Under NIR light irradiation of different power densities, MSCs tend to differentiate into adipocytes (low power, 0.5 W·cm^-2) or osteoblasts (high power, 6 W·cm^-2). The NIR light triggered anti-adhesive effect of a 4‑(hydroxymethyl)‑3-nitrobenzoic acid modified poly(ethylene glycol) coating on a substrate demonstrated these differentiation properties of MSCs, providing a new way to modulate bone regeneration in tissue engineering.

The photobiomodulation therapy under NIR light irradiation for bone healing

Several studies have demonstrated that NIR light irradiation therapy could be used to improve bone healing and the regeneration process. NIR light therapy at 790 nm was reported to guide bone tissue regeneration on rabbits' tibial fractures with wire osteosynthesis or internal rigid fixation [122-124]. In addition, 850 nm NIR light phototherapy demonstrated the same ability to stimulate cell proliferation and guide bone tissue regeneration in a rodent model [125]. Moreover, linear polarized NIR light irradiation (830 nm) could enhance the mechanical expansion of the rat sagittal suture by controlling the growth of the craniofacial skeleton [126]. These NIR light irradiations showed deep penetration in the bone defect region and stimulated bone healing, resulting in an increased deposition of calcium hydroxyapatite in the radiation regions [122].

Furthermore, Gokmenoglu et al. [127] reported that photobiomodulation therapy under NIR light irradiation could change the biochemical markers in peri-implant cervical fluid and the biological activities in the wound healing process. In that study, an LED device at a wavelength in the NIR region was applied to the surgical region, leading to a positive effect on the osseointegration process and implant stability after surgery. Similarly, the effect of LED (945 nm) therapy on the bone healing and tissue regeneration processes has also been investigated [128]. These studies demonstrated that low power LED therapy within the NIR region has a positive effect on tissue regeneration, especially in the early stage of repair. The results from those studies have shown that NIR light irradiation can accelerate the process of fracture healing and promote the formation of new bone tissue, providing great potential for the clinical treatment of bone fractures.

The photobiomodulation therapy under NIR light irradiation for dental treatment

Tooth movement during orthodontic therapy is usually associated with bone resorption on the pressure side and bone regeneration on the tension side [129]. Several strategies have been proposed to decrease the treatment time in orthodontic therapy. A multicenter clinical trial demonstrated that photobiomodulation under 850 nm NIR light changed the rates of tooth movement and promoted orthodontic alignment significantly in the early phase of treatment [130]. NIR light irradiation at a power density of 60 mW·cm^-2 was performed on the surface of the patients' cheek for 20 or 30 min every day or 60 min every week. Another study supported this conclusion, providing evidence that low level laser therapy accelerates bone remodeling and inhibits root resorption during orthodontic tooth movement in a rodent model [131]. The laser irradiation (810 nm, 5 W·cm^-2) in that study was performed on the labial and palatal sides of the tooth for 15 s every other day. Moreover, Gunji et al. [129] examined the effect of high frequency NIR diode laser irradiation with a wavelength of 910 nm on tooth movement. They reported that 910 nm NIR laser irradiation on periodontal tissue resulted in metabolic activation, which ultimately enhanced tooth movement during orthodontic treatment. Recently, the combined effects of mechanical force loading and Nd:YAG laser irradiation on bone metabolism have been investigated [132]. NIR laser irradiation at a wavelength of 1064 nm activated the expression of genes related to bone metabolism in osteoblast‑like cells, enhancing bone remodeling and tooth movement.

Besides the reported capability to enhance tooth movement, NIR light-assisted phototherapy has also been applied to regulate the inflammatory and repair processes of dental trauma. LED phototherapy (940 nm) of the periodontal ligament stimulated the proliferation of fibroblasts and increased the synthesis of the extracellular matrix, accelerating periodontal tissue repair [133]. Irradiation could also decrease the migration of inflammatory cells into periodontal tissues, thus reducing root resorption. Another study demonstrated that 810 nm laser phototherapy on the root surface, in continuous or pulsed modes, could reduce root resorption during the treatment of tooth replantation [134]. These studies suggested that NIR light‑assisted phototherapy might be efficient to decrease root resorption and enhance periodontal tissue healing after injury to periodontal tissue. However, Mitihiro et al. [135] reported that NIR LED (940 nm) phototherapy up to 48 h after tooth replantation did not improve the healing process, and even delayed periodontal ligament repair. Although phototherapy seems to show a promising effect in decreasing the inflammatory reaction, it may not be effective to avoid pulp necrosis, which damages the process of tissue repair after tooth replantation. The results of our literature search literature suggested that caution should be taken when using NIR light-assisted phototherapy in dental treatment. Determining the irradiation parameters, such as the wavelength, power density, mode of emission (discontinuous or continuous), duration of irradiation, and the irradiated region, is essential for successful dental treatment.

Current challenges and perspectives

In summary, NIR light can serve as an effective in vitro stimulation for targeted therapy because of its good tissue penetration ability, minimal invasiveness and high selectivity [50]. NIR light-assisted phototherapies have shown great potential to treat bone-related diseases and bone regeneration. Most of these phototherapies are based on a series of unique NIR light-responsive nanomaterials. These nanomaterials could exert their functions via multiple methods administration according to different therapeutic goals. They could be injected directly, or serve as a part of bioactive scaffolds and drug delivery systems, exhibiting efficient therapeutic performance in the pathological regions via generating local hyperthermia and increasing ROS concentrations under NIR light irradiation. The different applications of NIR light‑responsive nanomaterials to treat bone-related diseases and bone regeneration are summarized in Table 7. However, the photobiomodulation effect under the direct NIR light irradiation has also shown great potential to regulate cellular behaviors and the process of bone tissue regeneration. To date, a series of in vitro and in vivo studies have demonstrated the encouraging advantages of the NIR light-assisted phototherapies for bone-related disease and bone regeneration. However, it remains challenging to translate preclinical studies into clinical applications.

Firstly, the biosafety of NIR light-responsive nanomaterials should be considered. With the rapid development of nanotechnology, several kinds of nanomaterials, such as metal-based nanomaterials, carbon-based nanomaterials, and other related photosensitive nanostructures, have been involved in NIR light-assisted phototherapies to make them “smart”. Apart from their efficient photosensitive properties and attractive biocompatibility, there are still many challenges to overcome before clinical applications. Above all, the components of these nanomaterials should be nontoxic and biodegradable. The acute and long-term toxicity of these nanomaterials depend on their physicochemical properties, including their composition, size, shape, and surface charge. The acute and chronic pathological toxicity during the treatment period of these nanomaterials, as well as their renal or hepatobiliary elimination from the body, should be evaluated to guarantee their in vivo safety for further clinical translation [32]. In current phototherapies, most applied NIR light-responsive nanomaterials might have long-term toxicity, especially the nonbiodegradable inorganic nanoparticles. The nanomaterials with excellent biocompatibility and biodegradability, such as black and red phosphorus, are the preferred selections for various phototherapies. In addition, the size, shape and surface charge of the nanomaterials should be modified to minimize their cellular interactions with normal tissues, thereby avoiding nonspecific damage to normal cells. For example, the emerging MXenes have exhibited satisfactory photosensitive abilities, hydrophilic nature, and unique physiochemical properties, allowing them to meet the strict requirements of biomedicine. The large surface area and facile surface modification of the MXenes also endow them with better in vivo performance because of their reduced toxicity, enhanced colloidal stability, and extended circulation within the body [53, 54]. Providing nanomaterials with a biological mimic coating, such as liposomes and cell membranes, could also be a promising alternative for clinical translation [11]. In conclusion, these NIR light‑responsive nanomaterials should not induce any adverse effects and must receive Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval before human use. Currently, few FDA‑approved phototherapeutic agents, such as indocyanine green, have been applied in NIR light-assisted phototherapies [136, 137]. Increased efforts should be made to synthesize and design more nanomaterials with both high phototherapeutic efficiency and outstanding biocompatibility.

Secondly, NIR light-induced hyperthermia should be well controlled according to different therapeutic needs. The main side effect of NIR light-induced phototherapies for bone-related disease treatment is that local hyperthermia followed by NIR light irradiation can not only eliminate the cancer cells, bacteria, and inflammatory cells, but also might damage the normal cells and tissues when the temperature is above the threshold. The precise regulation of photothermal effect during the NIR light irradiation treatment is essential to promote the efficacy of phototherapies and minimize the damage. Considering the different therapeutic goals in the treatment of bone-related diseases, the parameters of NIR light irradiation to generate targeted hyperthermia within a reasonable temperature range should be carefully selected [21]. Generally speaking, local hyperthermia over 50 °C exerts highly effective phototherapeutic effects on pathological tissues, which is favorable for the treatment of bone cancers, infections, and inflammations. Under NIR light irradiation, the cancer tissues can be effectively ablated by photonic hyperthermia (over 50 °C) without recurrence [31, 44, 66]. Similarly, hyperthermia at almost 55 °C achieved a high antibacterial efficiency (99.995%) in the treatment of bone infections [15]. For bone regeneration therapies, the proposed mild local hyperthermia (40-42 °C), which is only about 3-5 °C higher than the normal human body temperature (37 °C), is recommended because of its abilities to accelerate bone healing and enhance the mineralization process in bone tissue regeneration [106]. Meanwhile, the temporary photothermal therapy within a suitable irradiation time might have a minimal impact on the tissue regeneration of the defect areas. The local inflammatory reaction secondary to PTT is similar to the primary phase of bone healing, which could accelerate bone tissue regeneration by recruiting precursor cells. Considering the effects of photobiomodulation on the adhesion, proliferation, and differentiation of stem cells, suitable mild local hyperthermia might have positive therapeutic effects on bone regeneration [44]. In future studies, more accurate and sensitive real-time monitoring techniques should be developed to adjust the irradiation parameters and avoid unnecessary damage following overheating [11].

Furthermore, the administration of NIR light could also be optimized. Although NIR light has deeper tissue penetration than the UV and Visual light, more effort should be made to overcome the laser penetration problem for the treatments of deep‑seated bone cancer, infection, or inflammation. The optimization of excitation conditions and the improvement of nano-bio interactions are also important. Local implantation and injection, rather than intravenous injection, could deliver effective amounts of photosensitive nanomaterials to targeted sites to obtain better therapeutic outcomes. Recently, phototherapy using an optical fiber NIR laser device was combined with surgery, in which the deep pathological lesions could be directly exposed to laser irradiation [138]. These emerging techniques using light administration could promote the efficiency of NIR light phototherapy, and advance its further translation into clinical applications.

In conclusion, NIR light-assisted phototherapies have shown great potential to treat bone-related disease and bone tissue regeneration. This noninvasive, precisely targeted treatment strategy could be considered as an effective tool to promote therapeutic efficacy. With better understandings of this technology, NIR light-assisted phototherapy could serve as a promising alternative for clinical applications.

Abbreviations

NIR: near infrared; PTT: photothermal therapy; PDT: photodynamic therapy; ROS: reactive oxygen species; NdYAG: neodymium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet; LED: light-emitting diodes; GO: graphene oxide; MWNTs: multi-walled carbon nanotubes; CDs: carbon dots; BP: black phosphorous; BMSCs: bone mesenchymal stem cells; DNA: deoxyribonucleic acid; BG: bioactive glass; Cu-TCPP: copper coordinated tetrakis (4-carboxyphenyl) porphyrin; TCP: tricalcium phosphate; 2D: two dimensional; ¹O₂: singlet oxygen; DOX: doxorubicin; PDA: polydopamine; BGN: bioactive glass nanoparticle; ZOL: zoledronic acid; ALN: alendronate; HAp: hydroxyapatite; S. aureus: Staphylococcus aureus; UCNPs: upconversion nanoparticles; RGD: arginine-glycine-aspartic acid; RGDC: arginine-glycine-aspartic-acid-cysteine; RA: rheumatoid arthritis; PRP: platelet-rich plasma; PA: photoacoustic; BS: bismuth sulfide; MSCs: mesenchymal stem cells; RUNX2: runt-related transcription factor 2; Sr: Strontium; PLGA: poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid); SDF-1α: stromal cell-derived factor 1α; BANC: biomimetic anti-inflammatory nanocapsule; BMP-2: bone morphogenetic protein-2; ASCs: adipose-derived stem cells; hMSCs: human mesenchymal stem cells; CCO: cytochrome c oxidase; IL: interleukin; VEGF: vascular endothelial growth factor.

Acknowledgements

This study was supported by grants from the Beijing Natural Science Foundation (7192228) and from the Young Elite Scientist Sponsorship Program by CAST (2015QNRC001).

Competing Interests

The authors have declared that no competing interest exists.

References

1. Shi C, Wu T, He Y, Zhang Y, Fu D. Recent advances in bone-targeted therapy. Pharmacol Ther. 2020;207:107473

2. Yang Y, Aw J, Xing B. Nanostructures for NIR light-controlled therapies. Nanoscale. 2017;9:3698-718

3. Zhao W, Zhao Y, Wang Q, Liu T, Sun J, Zhang R. Remote Light-Responsive Nanocarriers for Controlled Drug Delivery: Advances and Perspectives. Small. 2019;15:e1903060

4. Son J, Yi G, Yoo J, Park C, Koo H, Choi HS. Light-responsive nanomedicine for biophotonic imaging and targeted therapy. Adv Drug Deliv Rev. 2019;138:133-47

5. Wan Z, Zhang P, Liu Y, Lv L, Zhou Y. Four-dimensional bioprinting: Current developments and applications in bone tissue engineering. Acta Biomater. 2020;101:26-42

6. Juzenas P, Juzeniene A, Kaalhus O, Iani V, Moan J. Noninvasive fluorescence excitation spectroscopy during application of 5-aminolevulinic acid in vivo. Photochem Photobiol Sci. 2002;10:745-8

7. Salehpour F, Cassano P, Rouhi N, Hamblin MR, De Taboada L. et al. Penetration profiles of visible and near-infrared lasers and light-emitting diode light through the head tissues in animal and human species: A Review of Literature. Photobiomodul Photomed Laser Surg. 2019;37(10):581-95

8. Saneja A, Kumar R, Arora D, Kumar S, Panda AK, Jaglan S. Recent advances in near-infrared light-responsive nanocarriers for cancer therapy. Drug Discov Today. 2018;23:1115-25

9. Yang G, Liu J, Wu Y, Feng L, Liu Z. Near-infrared-light responsive nanoscale drug delivery systems for cancer treatment. Coordin Chem Rev. 2016;320-321:100-17

10. Yue X, Zhang Q, Dai Z. Near-infrared light-activatable polymeric nanoformulations for combined therapy and imaging of cancer. Adv Drug Deliver Rev. 2017;115:155-70

11. Liu Y, Bhattarai P, Dai Z, Chen X. Photothermal therapy and photoacoustic imaging via nanotheranostics in fighting cancer. Chem Soc Rev. 2019;48:2053-108

12. Dariva CG, Coelho JFJ, Serra AC. Near infrared light-triggered nanoparticles using singlet oxygen photocleavage for drug delivery systems. J Control Release. 2019;294:337-54

13. Shahbazi MA, Faghfouri L, Ferreira MPA, Figueiredo P, Maleki H, Sefat F. et al. The versatile biomedical applications of bismuth-based nanoparticles and composites: therapeutic, diagnostic, biosensing, and regenerative properties. Chem Soc Rev. 2020;49:1253-321

14. Luo S, Zhang E, Su Y, Cheng T, Shi C. A review of NIR dyes in cancer targeting and imaging. Biomaterials. 2011;32:7127-38

15. Su K, Tan L, Liu X, Cui Z, Zheng Y, Li B. et al. Rapid photo-sonotherapy for clinical treatment of bacterial infected bone implants by creating oxygen deficiency using sulfur doping. ACS nano. 2020;14:2077-89

16. Yuan Z, Tao B, He Y, Mu C, Liu G, Zhang J. et al. Remote eradication of biofilm on titanium implant via near-infrared light triggered photothermal/photodynamic therapy strategy. Biomaterials. 2019;223:119479

17. Yuan Z, Tao B, He Y, Liu J, Lin C, Shen X. et al. Biocompatible MoS₂/PDA-RGD coating on titanium implant with antibacterial property via intrinsic ROS-independent oxidative stress and NIR irradiation. Biomaterials. 2019;217:119290

18. Lu Y, Li L, Lin Z, Wang L, Lin L, Li M. et al. A New Treatment Modality for Rheumatoid Arthritis: Combined Photothermal and Photodynamic Therapy using Cu7.2S4 Nanoparticles. Adv Healthc Mater. 2018;7:e1800013

19. Zhang X, Cheng G, Xing X, Liu J, Cheng Y, Ye T. et al. Near-infrared light-triggered porous AuPd alloy nanoparticles to produce mild localized heat to accelerate bone regeneration. J Phys Chem Lett. 2019;10:4185-91

20. Fu J, Liu X, Tan L, Cui Z, Zheng Y, Liang Y. et al. Photoelectric-responsive extracellular matrix for bone engineering. ACS nano. 2019;13:13581-94

21. Sanchez-Casanova S, Martin-Saavedra FM, Escudero-Duch C, Falguera Uceda MI, Prieto M, Arruebo M. et al. Local delivery of bone morphogenetic protein-2 from near infrared-responsive hydrogels for bone tissue regeneration. Biomaterials. 2020;241:119909

22. Yin C, Zhao Q, Li W, Zhao Z, Wang J, Deng T. et al. Biomimetic anti-inflammatory nano-capsule serves as a cytokine blocker and M2 polarization inducer for bone tissue repair. Acta Biomater. 2020;102:416-26

23. Xiao W, Wang P, Ou C, Huang X, Tang Y, Wu M. et al. 2-pyridone-functionalized Aza-BODIPY photosensitizer for imaging-guided sustainable phototherapy. Biomaterials. 2018;183:1-9

24. Yue W, Chen L, Yu L, Zhou B, Yin H, Ren W. et al. Checkpoint blockade and nanosonosensitizer-augmented noninvasive sonodynamic therapy combination reduces tumour growth and metastases in mice. Nat Commun. 2019;10:2025

25. Rao L, Meng QF, Huang Q, Liu P, Bu LL, Kondamareddy KK. et al. Photocatalytic degradation of cell membrane coatings for controlled drug release. Adv Healthc Mater. 2016;5:1420-7

26. Zhao Y, Guo Q, Dai X, Wei X, Yu Y, Chen X. et al. A biomimetic non-antibiotic approach to eradicate drug-resistant infections. Adv Mater. 2019;31:e1806024

27. Zhang G, Zhang X, Yang Y, Chi R, Shi J, Hang R. et al. Dual light-induced in situ antibacterial activities of biocompatibleTiO₂/MoS₂/PDA/RGD nanorod arrays on titanium. Biomater Sci. 2020;8:391-404

28. Tan L, Li J, Liu X, Cui Z, Yang X, Zhu S. et al. Rapid biofilm eradication on bone implants using red phosphorus and near-infrared light. Adv Mater. 2018;30:e1801808

29. Wang X, Shao J, Abd El Raouf M, Xie H, Huang H, Wang H. et al. Near-infrared light-triggered drug delivery system based on black phosphorus for in vivo bone regeneration. Biomaterials. 2018;179:164-74

30. Kansara M, Teng MW, Smyth MJ, Thomas DM. Translational biology of osteosarcoma. Nat Rev Cancer. 2014;14:722-35

31. Pan S, Yin J, Yu L, Zhang C, Zhu Y, Gao Y. et al. 2D MXene-integrated 3D-printing scaffolds for augmented osteosarcoma phototherapy and accelerated tissue reconstruction. Adv Sci. 2020;7:1901511

32. Lin H, Gao S, Dai C, Chen Y, Shi J. A two-dimensional biodegradable niobium carbide (MXene) for photothermal tumor eradication in NIR-I and NIR-II Biowindows. J Am Chem Soc. 2017;139(45):16235-47

33. Wang S, Ma X, Hong X, Cheng Y, Tian Y, Zhao S. et al. adjuvant photothermal therapy inhibits local recurrences after breast-conserving surgery with little skin damage. ACS nano. 2018;12(1):662-70

34. Zhang F, Han X, Hu Y, Wang S, Liu S, Pan X. et al. Interventional photothermal therapy enhanced brachytherapy: A New Strategy to Fight Deep Pancreatic Cancer. Adv Sci. 2019;6:1801507

35. Liu H, Li C, Qian Y, Hu L, Fang J, Tong W. et al. Magnetic-induced graphene quantum dots for imaging-guided photothermal therapy in the second near-infrared window. Biomaterials. 2020;232:119700

36. Jaque D, Martínez Maestro L, del Rosal B, Haro-Gonzalez P, Benayas A, Plaza JL. et al. Nanoparticles for photothermal therapies. Nanoscale. 2014;6:9494-530

37. Lenna S, Bellotti C, Duchi S, Martella E, Columbaro M, Dozza B. et al. Mesenchymal stromal cells mediated delivery of photoactive nanoparticles inhibits osteosarcoma growth in vitro and in a murine in vivo ectopic model. J Exp Clin Cancer Res. 2020;39:40

38. Chen F, Cai W. Nanomedicine for targeted photothermal cancer therapy: where are we now?. Nanomedicine. 2015;10:1-3

39. Li X, Kwon N, Guo T, Liu Z, Yoon J. Innovative Strategies for Hypoxic-Tumor Photodynamic Therapy. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl. 2018;57:11522-31

40. Dang J, He H, Chen D, Yin L. Manipulating tumor hypoxia toward enhanced photodynamic therapy (PDT). Biomate Sci. 2017;5:1500-11

41. Koudinova NV, Pinthus JH, Brandis A, Brenner O, Bendel P, Ramon J. et al. Photodynamic therapy with Pd-Bacteriopheophorbide (TOOKAD): successful in vivo treatment of human prostatic small cell carcinoma xenografts. Inter J Cancer. 2003;104:782-9

42. Geng B, Qin H, Shen W, Li P, Fang F, Li X. et al. Carbon dot/WS₂ heterojunctions for NIR-II enhanced photothermal therapy of osteosarcoma and bone regeneration. Chem Eng J. 2020;383:123102

43. Dang W, Li T, Li B, Ma H, Zhai D, Wang X. et al. A bifunctional scaffold with CuFeSe₂ nanocrystals for tumor therapy and bone reconstruction. Biomaterials. 2018;160:92-106

44. Yang Q, Yin H, Xu T, Zhu D, Yin J, Chen Y. et al. Engineering 2D mesoporous silica@MXene-integrated 3D-printing scaffolds for combinatory osteosarcoma therapy and NO-augmented bone regeneration. Small. 2020;16:e1906814

45. Xiang H, Yang Q, Gao Y, Zhu D, Pan S, Xu T. et al. Cocrystal strategy toward multifunctional 3D-printing scaffolds enables NIR-activated photonic osteosarcoma hyperthermia and enhanced bone defect regeneration. Adv Func Mater. 2020 1909938

46. Lu Y, Li L, Lin Z, Li M, Hu X, Zhang Y. et al. Enhancing osteosarcoma killing and CT imaging using ultrahigh drug loading and NIR-responsive bismuth sulfide@mesoporous silica nanoparticles. Adv Healthc Mater. 2018;7:e1800602

47. Cicuéndez M, Flores J, Oliveira H, Portolés MT, Vallet-Regí M, Vila M. et al. Metabolomic response of osteosarcoma cells to nanographene oxide-mediated hyperthermia. Mater Sci Eng C Mater Biol Appl. 2018;91:340-8

48. Zhou Z, Fan T, Yan Y, Zhang S, Zhou Y, Deng H. et al. One stone with two birds: Phytic acid-capped platinum nanoparticles for targeted combination therapy of bone tumors. Biomaterials. 2019;194:130-8

49. Lin Z, Liu Y, Ma X, Hu S, Zhang J, Wu Q. et al. Photothermal ablation of bone metastasis of breast cancer using PEGylated multi-walled carbon nanotubes. Sci Rep. 2015;5:11709

50. Wang C, Cai X, Zhang J, Wang X, Wang Y, Ge H. et al. Trifolium-like platinum nanoparticle-mediated photothermal therapy inhibits tumor growth and osteolysis in a bone metastasis model. Small. 2015;11:2080-6

51. Jie S, Guo X, Ouyang Z. Tumor ablation using novel photothermal Na_xWO₃ nanoparticles against breast cancer osteolytic bone metastasis. Int J Nanomed. 2019;14:7353-62

52. Tang B, Li WL, Chang Y, Yuan B, Wu Y, Zhang MT. et al. A supramolecular radical dimer: High-efficiency NIR-II photothermal conversion and therapy. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl. 2019;58:15526-31

53. Lin H, Chen Y, Shi J. Insights into 2D MXenes for versatile biomedical applications: Current advances and challenges ahead. Adv Sci. 2018;5(10):1800518

54. Soleymaniha M, Shahbazi MA, Rafieerad AR, Maleki A, Amiri A, Promoting role of MXene nanosheets in biomedical sciences. Therapeutic and biosensing innovations. Adv Healthc Mater. 2019;8(1):e1801137

55. Ding X, Liow CH, Zhang M, Huang R, Li C, Shen H. et al. Surface plasmon resonance enhanced light absorption and photothermal therapy in the second near-infrared window. J Am Chem Soc. 2014;136(44):15684-93

56. Tsai MF, Chang SH, Cheng FY, Shanmugam V, Cheng YS, Su CH. et al. Au nanorod design as light-absorber in the first and second biological near-infrared windows for in vivo photothermal therapy. ACS nano. 2013;7(6):5330-42

57. Antaris AL, Chen H, Cheng K, Sun Y, Hong G, Qu C. et al. A small-molecule dye for NIR-II imaging. Nat Mater. 2016;15(2):235-42

58. Raucci MG, Fasolino I, Caporali M, Serrano-Ruiz M, Soriente A, Peruzzini M. et al. Exfoliated black phosphorus promotes in vitro bone regeneration and suppresses osteosarcoma progression through cancer-related inflammation inhibition. ACS Appl Mater Inter. 2019;11:9333-42

59. Ma H, Jiang C, Zhai D, Luo Y, Chen Y, Lv F. et al. A bifunctional biomaterial with photothermal effect for tumor therapy and bone regeneration. Adv Func Mater. 2016;26:1197-208

60. Wang L, Long NJ, Li L, Lu Y, Li M, Cao J. et al. Multi-functional bismuth-doped bioglasses: combining bioactivity and photothermal response for bone tumor treatment and tissue repair. Light Sci Appl. 2018;7:1

61. Zhang W, Gu J, Li K, Zhao J, Ma H, Wu C. et al. A hydrogenated black TiO₂ coating with excellent effects for photothermal therapy of bone tumor and bone regeneration. Mater Sci Eng C Mater Biol Appl. 2019;102:458-70

62. Zhao P, Ge Y, Liu X, Ke Q, Zhang J, Zhu Z. et al. Ordered arrangement of hydrated GdPO₄ nanorods in magnetic chitosan matrix promotes tumor photothermal therapy and bone regeneration against breast cancer bone metastases. Chem Eng J. 2020;381:122694

63. Yang F, Lu J, Ke Q, Peng X, Guo Y, Xie X. Magnetic mesoporous calcium sillicate/chitosan porous scaffolds for enhanced bone regeneration and photothermal-chemotherapy of osteosarcoma. Sci Rep. 2018;8:7345

64. Lu JW, Yang F, Ke QF, Xie XT, Guo YP. Magnetic nanoparticles modified-porous scaffolds for bone regeneration and photothermal therapy against tumors. Nanomed Nanotechnol. 2018;14:811-22

65. Dang W, Ma B, Li B, Huan Z, Ma N, Zhu H. et al. 3D printing of metal-organic framework nanosheets-structured scaffolds with tumor therapy and bone construction. Biofabrication. 2020;12:025005

66. Wang H, Zeng X, Pang L, Wang H, Lin B, Deng Z. et al. Integrative treatment of anti-tumor/bone repair by combination of MoS₂ nanosheets with 3D printed bioactive borosilicate glass scaffolds. Chem Eng J. 2020;396:125081

67. Zhang Y, Zhu Y, Chen F, Lu B. Dopamine-modified highly porous hydroxyapatite microtube networks with efficient near-infrared photothermal effect, enhanced protein adsorption and mineralization performance. Colloid Surface B. 2017;159:337-348

68. Lu Y, Li L, Li M, Lin Z, Wang L, Zhang Y. et al. Zero-dimensional carbon dots enhance bone regeneration, osteosarcoma ablation, and clinical bacterial eradication. Bioconjugate Chem. 2018;29:2982-93

69. Guo Z, Jiang N, Moore J, McCoy CP, Ziminska M, Rafferty C. et al. Nanoscale hybrid coating enables multifunctional tissue scaffold for potential multimodal therapeutic applications. Acs Appl Mater Inter. 2019;11:27269-78

70. Saber-Samandari S, Mohammadi-Aghdam M, Saber-Samandari S. A novel magnetic bifunctional nanocomposite scaffold for photothermal therapy and tissue engineering. Int J Biol Macromol. 2019;138:810-8

71. Xu C, Ma B, Peng J, Gao L, Xu Y, Huan Z. et al. Tricalcium silicate/graphene oxide bone cement with photothermal properties for tumor ablation. J Mater Chem B. 2019;7:2808-18

72. Qi C, Deng Y, Xu L, Yang C, Zhu Y, Wang G. et al. A sericin/graphene oxide composite scaffold as a biomimetic extracellular matrix for structural and functional repair of calvarial bone. Theranostics. 2020;10(2):741-56

73. Fang H, Luo C, Liu S, Zhou M, Zeng Y, Hou J. et al. A biocompatible vascularized graphene oxide (GO)-collagen chamber with osteoinductive and anti-fibrosis effects promotes bone regeneration in vivo. Theranostics. 2020;10(6):2759-72

74. Dang W, Ma B, Huan Z, Lin R, Wang X, Li T. et al. LaB₆ surface chemistry-reinforced scaffolds for treating bone tumors and bone defects. Appl Mater Today. 2019;16:42-55

75. Shim G, Ko S, Kim D, Le QV, Park GT, Lee J. et al. Light-switchable systems for remotely controlled drug delivery. J Control Release. 2017;267:67-79

76. Xue Y, Niu W, Wang M, Chen M, Guo Y, Lei B. Engineering a biodegradable multifunctional antibacterial bioactive nanosystem for enhancing tumor photothermo-chemotherapy and bone regeneration. ACS nano. 2020;14:442-53

77. Sun W, Ge K, Jin Y, Han Y, Zhang H, Zhou G. et al. Bone-targeted nanoplatform combining zoledronate and photothermal therapy to treat breast cancer bone metastasis. ACS nano. 2019;13:7556-67

78. Dong Z, Gong H, Gao M, Zhu W, Sun X, Feng L. et al. Polydopamine nanoparticles as a versatile molecular loading platform to enable imaging-guided cancer combination therapy. Theranostics. 2016;6(7):1031-42

79. Zhao H, Chao Y, Liu J, Huang J, Pan J, Guo W. et al. Polydopamine coated single-walled carbon nanotubes as a versatile platform with radionuclide labeling for multimodal tumor imaging and therapy. Theranostics. 2016;6(11):1833-43

80. Wang Y, Huang Q, He X, Chen H, Zou Y, Li Y. et al. Multifunctional melanin-like nanoparticles for bone-targeted chemo-photothermal therapy of malignant bone tumors and osteolysis. Biomaterials. 2018;183:10-19

81. Luo S, Wu J, Jia Z, Tang P, Sheng J, Xie C. et al. An injectable, bifunctional hydrogel with photothermal effects for tumor therapy and bone regeneration. Macromol Biosci. 2019;19:e1900047

82. Gu W, Zhang T, Gao J, Wang Y, Li D, Zhao Z. et al. Albumin-bioinspired iridium oxide nanoplatform with high photothermal conversion efficiency for synergistic chemo-photothermal of osteosarcoma. Drug Deliv. 2019;26:918-27

83. Pan W, Dai C, Li Y, Yin Y, Gong L, Machuki JOa. et al. PRP-chitosan thermoresponsive hydrogel combined with black phosphorus nanosheets as injectable biomaterial for biotherapy and phototherapy treatment of rheumatoid arthritis. Biomaterials. 2020;239:119851

84. Wang X, Xu S, Zhou S, Xu W, Leary M, Choong P. et al. Topological design and additive manufacturing of porous metals for bone scaffolds and orthopaedic implants: A review. Biomaterials. 2016;83:127-41

85. Neoh KG, Hu X, Zheng D, Kang ET. Balancing osteoblast functions and bacterial adhesion on functionalized titanium surfaces. Biomaterials. 2012;33:2813-22

86. Zhao Z, Yan R, Yi X, Li J, Rao J, Guo Z. et al. Bacteria-activated theranostic nanoprobes against methicillin-resistant staphylococcus aureus infection. ACS nano. 2017;11:4428-38

87. Min J, Choi KY, Dreaden EC, Padera RF, Braatz RD, Spector M. et al. Designer Dual Therapy Nanolayered Implant Coatings Eradicate Biofilms and Accelerate Bone Tissue Repair. ACS nano. 2016;10:4441-50

88. Liu Y, Busscher HJ, Zhao B, Li Y, Zhang Z, van der Mei HC. et al. Surface-Adaptive, Antimicrobially Loaded, Micellar Nanocarriers with Enhanced Penetration and Killing Efficiency in Staphylococcal Biofilms. ACS nano. 2016;10:4779-89

89. Cabiscol E, Tamarit J, Ros J. Oxidative stress in bacteria and protein damage by reactive oxygen species. Int Microbiol. 2000;3:3-8

90. Hong L, Liu X, Tan L, Cui Z, Yang X, Liang Y. et al. Rapid biofilm elimination on bone implants using near-infrared-activated inorganic semiconductor heterostructures. Adv Healthc Mater. 2019;8:e1900835

91. Hu Z, Yuan L, Liu Z, Shen Z, Yu JC. An elemental phosphorus photocatalyst with a record high hydrogen evolution efficiency. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl. 2016;55:9580-5

92. Huang B, Tan L, Liu X, Li J, Wu S. A facile fabrication of novel stuff with antibacterial property and osteogenic promotion utilizing red phosphorus and near-infrared light. Bioact Mater. 2018;4:17-21

93. Liu J, Yu M, Zeng G, Cao J, Wang Y, Ding T. et al. Dual antibacterial behavior of a curcumin-upconversion photodynamic nanosystem for efficient eradication of drug-resistant bacteria in a deep joint infection. J Mat Chem B. 2018;6:7854-61

94. Tang C. Research of pathogenesis and novel therapeutics in arthritis. Int J Mol Sci. 2019;20:1646

95. Lu Y, Li L, Lin Z, Wang L, Lin L, Li M. et al. A new treatment modality for rheumatoid arthritis: Combined photothermal and photodynamic therapy using Cu_7.2 S₄ nanoparticles. Adv Healthc Mate. 2018;7:e1800013

96. Kim HJ, Lee S-M, Park K-H, Mun CH, Park Y-B, Yoo K-H. Drug-loaded gold/iron/gold plasmonic nanoparticles for magnetic targeted chemo-photothermal treatment of rheumatoid arthritis. Biomaterials. 2015;61:95-102

97. Lin J, Wang S, Huang P, Wang Z, Chen S, Niu G. et al. Photosensitizer-loaded gold vesicles with strong plasmonic coupling effect for imaging-guided photothermal/photodynamic therapy. ACS nano. 2013;7:5320-9

98. Lee SM, Kim HJ, Ha YJ, Park YN, Lee SK, Park YB. et al. Targeted chemo-photothermal treatments of rheumatoid arthritis using gold half-shell multifunctional nanoparticles. ACS nano. 2013;7:50-7

99. Zhao Y, Wei C, Chen X, Liu J, Yu Q, Liu Y. et al. Drug delivery system based on near-infrared light-responsive molybdenum disulfide nanosheets controls the high-efficiency release of dexamethasone to inhibit inflammation and treat osteoarthritis. Acs Appl Mater Inter. 2019;11:11587-601

100. Zhang X, Zhang X, Wang X, Wang T, Bai B, Zhang N. et al. Efficient delivery of triptolide plus a miR-30-5p inhibitor through the use of near infrared laser responsive or CADY modified MSNs for efficacy in rheumatoid arthritis therapeutics. Front Bioeng Biotechnol. 2020;8:170

101. Hamblin MR. Mechanisms and mitochondrial redox signaling in photobiomodulation. Photochem Photobiol. 2018;94:199-212

102. Desmet KD, Paz DA, Corry JJ, Eells JT, Wong-Riley MT, Henry MM. et al. Clinical and experimental applications of NIR-LED photobiomodulation. Photomed Laser Surg. 2006;24:121-8

103. Talukdar Y, Rashkow JT, Patel S, Lalwani G, Bastidas J, Khan S. et al. Nanofilm generated non-pharmacological anabolic bone stimulus. J Biomed Mater Res A. 2020;108:178-86

104. Chen J, Shi ZD, Ji X, Morales J, Zhang J, Kaur N. et al. Enhanced osteogenesis of human mesenchymal stem cells by periodic heat shock in self-assembling peptide hydrogel. Tissue Eng Part A. 2013;19(5-6):716-28

105. Chen S, Du X, Wang T, Jia L, Huang D, Chen W. Synthesis of near-infrared responsive gold nanorod-doped gelatin/hydroxyapatite composite microspheres with controlled photo-thermal property. Ceram Int. 2018;44:900-4

106. Tong L, Liao Q, Zhao Y, Huang H, Gao A, Zhang W. et al. Near-infrared light control of bone regeneration with biodegradable photothermal osteoimplant. Biomaterials. 2019;193:1-11

107. Miao Y, Shi X, Li Q, Hao L, Liu L, Liu X. et al. Engineering natural matrices with black phosphorus nanosheets to generate multi-functional therapeutic nanocomposite hydrogels. Biomater Sci. 2019;7:4046-59

108. Churchill HO, Jarillo-Herrero P. Two-dimensional crystals: phosphorus joins the family. Nat Nanotechnol. 2014;9:330-1

109. Doganov RA, O'Farrell EC, Koenig SP, Yeo Y, Ziletti A, Carvalho A. et al. Transport properties of pristine few-layer black phosphorus by van der Waals passivation in an inert atmosphere. Nat Commun. 2015;6:6647

110. Kang H, Zhang K, Pan Q, Lin S, Wong DSH, Li J. et al. Remote control of intracellular calcium using upconversion nanotransducers regulates stem cell differentiation in vivo. Adv Func Mater. 2018;28:1802642

111. Tuncaboylu DC, Friess F, Wischke C, Lendlein A. A multifunctional multimaterial system for on-demand protein release. J Control Release. 2018;284:240-7

112. Hamblin MR. Mechanisms and mitochondrial redox signaling in photobiomodulation. Photochem Photobiol. 2018;94:199-212

113. AlGhamdi KM, Kumar A, Moussa NA. Low-level laser therapy: a useful technique for enhancing the proliferation of various cultured cells. Laser Med Sci. 2012;27:237-49

114. Ates GB, Can AA, Gulsoy M. Investigation of photobiomodulation potentiality by 635 and 809 nm lasers on human osteoblasts. Laser Med Sci. 2017;32:591-9

115. Zare F, Moradi A, Fallahnezhad S, Ghoreishi SK, Amini A, Chien S. et al. Photobiomodulation with 630 plus 810 nm wavelengths induce more in vitro cell viability of human adipose stem cells than human bone marrow-derived stem cells. J Photoch Photobio B. 2019;201:111658

116. Kunimatsu R, Gunji H, Tsuka Y, Yoshimi Y, Awada T, Sumi K. et al. Effects of high-frequency near-infrared diode laser irradiation on the proliferation and migration of mouse calvarial osteoblasts. Laser Med Sci. 2018;33:959-66

117. Peat FJ, Colbath AC, Bentsen LM, Goodrich LR, King MR. In vitro effects of high-intensity laser photobiomodulation on equine bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell viability and cytokine expression. Photomed Laser Surg. 2018;36:83-91

118. Wang Y, Huang Y, Wang Y, Lyu P, Hamblin MR. Red (660 nm) or near-infrared (810 nm) photobiomodulation stimulates, while blue (415 nm), green (540 nm) light inhibits proliferation in human adipose-derived stem cells. Sci Rep. 2017;7:7781

119. Wang Y, Huang Y, Wang Y, Lyu P, Hamblin MR. Photobiomodulation (blue and green light) encourages osteoblastic-differentiation of human adipose-derived stem cells: role of intracellular calcium and light-gated ion channels. Sci Rep. 2016;6:33719

120. Tani A, Chellini F, Giannelli M, Nosi D, Zecchi-Orlandini S, Sassoli C. Red (635 nm), near-Infrared (808 nm) and violet-blue (405 nm) photobiomodulation potentiality on human osteoblasts and mesenchymal stromal cells: A morphological and molecular in vitro study. Int J Mol Sci. 2018;19:1946

121. Yan Z, Qin H, Ren J, Qu X. Photocontrolled multidirectional differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells on an upconversion substrate. Angew Chem Int Edit. 2018;57:11182-7

122. Lopes CB, Pacheco MT, Silveira L Jr, Duarte J, Cangussú MC, Pinheiro AL. The effect of the association of NIR laser therapy BMPs, and guided bone regeneration on tibial fractures treated with wire osteosynthesis: Raman spectroscopy study. J Photoch Photobio B. 2007;89:125-30

123. Lopes CB, Pacheco MT, Silveira L Jr, Cangussú MC, Pinheiro AL. The effect of the association of near infrared laser therapy, bone morphogenetic proteins, and guided bone regeneration on tibial fractures treated with internal rigid fixation: a Raman spectroscopic study. J Biomed Mater Res A. 2010;94:1257-63

124. Pinheiro AL, Santos NR, Oliveira PC, Aciole GT, Ramos TA, Gonzalez TA. et al. The efficacy of the use of IR laser phototherapy associated to biphasic ceramic graft and guided bone regeneration on surgical fractures treated with wire osteosynthesis: a comparative laser fluorescence and Raman spectral study on rabbits. Laser Med Sci. 2013;28:815-22

125. Pinheiro AL, Soares LG, Aciole GT, Correia NA, Barbosa AF, Ramalho LM. et al. Light microscopic description of the effects of laser phototherapy on bone defects grafted with mineral trioxide aggregate, bone morphogenetic proteins, and guided bone regeneration in a rodent model. J Biomed Mater Res A. 2011;98:212-21

126. Sasaki A, Touma Y, Ishino Y, Tanaka E, Aoyama J, Hanaoka K. et al. Linear polarized near-infrared irradiation stimulates mechanical expansion of the rat sagittal suture. Luminescence. 2003;18:58-60

127. Gokmenoglu C, Ozmeric N, Erguder I, Elgun S. The effect of light-emitting diode photobiomodulation on implant stability and biochemical markers in peri-implant crevicular fluid. Photomed Laser Surg. 2014;32:138-45

128. Diamantino AG, Nicolau RA, Costa DR, de Barros Almeida AP, de Miranda Mato DX, de Oliveira MA. et al. Effect of non-coherent infrared light (LED, λ945 ± 20 nm) on bone repair in diabetic rats-morphometric and spectral analyses. Laser Med Sci. 2017;32:1041-9

129. Gunji H, Kunimatsu R, Tsuka Y, Yoshimi Y, Sumi K, Awada T. et al. Effect of high-frequency near-infrared diode laser irradiation on periodontal tissues during experimental tooth movement in rats. Lasers Surg Med. 2018 doi: 10.1002/lsm.22797

130. Kau CH, Kantarci A, Shaughnessy T, Vachiramon A, Santiwong P, de la Fuente A. et al. Photobiomodulation accelerates orthodontic alignment in the early phase of treatment. Prog Orthod. 2013;14:30

131. Suzuki SS, Garcez AS, Suzuki H, Ervolino E, Moon W, Ribeiro MS. Low-level laser therapy stimulates bone metabolism and inhibits root resorption during tooth movement in a rodent model. J Biophotonics. 2016;9:1222-35

132. Tsuka Y, Kunimatsu R, Gunji H, Abe T, Medina CC, Nakajima K. et al. Examination of the effect of the combined use of Nd: YAG laser irradiation and mechanical force loading on bone metabolism using cultured human osteoblasts. J Laser Med Sci. 2020;11:138-43

133. Fonseca PD, de Lima FM, Higashi DT, Koyama DF, Toginho Filho Dde O, Dias IF. et al. Effects of light emitting diode (LED) therapy at 940 nm on inflammatory root resorption in rats. Laser Med Sci. 2013;28:49-55

134. Carvalho Edos S, Costa FT, Campos MS, Anbinder AL, Neves AC, Habitante SM. et al. Root surface treatment using diode laser in delayed tooth replantation: radiographic and histomorphometric analyses in rats. Dent Traumatol. 2012;28:429-36

135. Pigatto Mitihiro D, de Paula Ramos S, Corazza Montero J, Alves Campos A, de Oliveira Toginho Filho D, Dezan Garbelini CC. Effects of near-infrared LED therapy on experimental tooth replantation in rats. Dent Traumatol. 2017;33:32-7

136. Xu L, Wang SB, Xu C, Han D, Ren XH, Zhang XZ. et al. Multifunctional albumin-based delivery system generated by programmed assembly for Tumor-Targeted Multimodal Therapy and Imaging. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces. 2019;11(42):38385-94

137. Chen Q, Hu Q, Dukhovlinova E, Chen G, Ahn S, Wang C. et al. Photothermal therapy promotes tumor infiltration and antitumor activity of CAR T cells. Adv Mater. 2019;31(23):e1900192

138. Yang J, Chandwani R, Gopinatth V, Boyce T, Pflugfelder SC, Huang D. et al. Near-infrared laser thermal conjunctivoplasty. Sci Rep. 2018;8(1):3863

139. Yuan Z, Tao B, He Y, Liu J, Lin C, Shen X. et al. Biocompatible MoS₂/PDA-RGD coating on titanium implant with antibacterial property via intrinsic ROS-independent oxidative stress and NIR irradiation. Biomaterials. 2019;217:119290

Author contact

Corresponding authors: Yongsheng Zhou, Department of Prosthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology, 22 Zhongguancun Avenue South, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, P.R. China. Office: 86-10-82195070. Fax: 86-10-62173402. E-mail: kqzhouyshpku.edu.cn; Longwei Lv, Department of Prosthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology, 22 Zhongguancun Avenue South, Haidian District, Beijing 100081, P.R. China. E-mail: lvlwedu.cn

Received 2020-6-22
Accepted 2020-9-17
Published 2020-9-26

Citation styles

©2024 Ivyspring International Publisher. Terms of use